Director: Karan Johar.
Starring: Shah Rukh Khan, Kajol, Yuvaan Makaar and Zarina Wahab
Distributor: Twentieth Century Fox
Runtime: 161 mins. Reviewed in Nov 2011

| |

Rating notes: Mature themes and violence

Despite the fact that September 11 divided the world, the film’s messages are not about religious bias or hatred, terrorism, racial discrimination, or autism. What drives Rizwan is his knowledge that the world is divided into good people and bad people, and his goal in life is to find the former. It is good, not evil, that triumphs in this movie, and the film carries the message very strongly that what ultimately counts in life is love, humanity and goodness. Tragedy hits the couple when they lose Sam, just as tragedy hit the US as a nation in 2001. But as terrorism makes its mark, and attitudes to Muslims and other races change, life continues to go on. The movie shows how two people, caught in the turmoil, manage to repair their lives.

At one level, this film can be described as mawkish, ridiculously sentimental and at times histrionically acted. It is a mishmash of most of the world’s problems all rolled into one, including exploding aeroplanes, racial discrimination, raging hurricanes, prison torture, the election of America’s first black President, and alienating patriotic fervour and bias. But in the awfulness of the mix, there is a wonderful exhilaration, and at the core of that emotion is a giant of a performance by Shah Rukh Khan, who emotionally captures the adult Rizwan with his almost every movement. The film unmercifully tugs at the heart strings in its wide, social sweep, but there is a tender, endearing moment for everyone tucked away somewhere in the mix.

The soundtrack is composed by Shankar-Ehsaan-Loy, and the lyrics by Niranjan Iyengar. Not unexpectedly for a movie of this kind, it captures some of its Bollywood style by dancing and singing in the streets, and music features prominently. The film is also partly a road movie, as Rizwan winds his way across America to meet Mandira’s challenge and explain things to the President. There is excellent cinematography by Ravi K. Chandran to support the film’s mood.

This is a complex movie, with many themes. It lacks coherence overall, but plugs its core messages about humanity relentlessly well. The movie is a story of love that goes wrong in the aftermath of one of the world’s biggest terrorist attacks. It aims to appeal to international audiences well beyond India, and it does so sensitively and enthusiastically. The film goes over the top in many places, but you can’t stop responding to it positively, as the director’s obvious manipulations of your emotions do their work.